Los Angeles Office Location
Hennig Ruiz & Singh
Not sure if you have a legal case? Call us to talk to a lawyer:
Free Consultations
One Of The Most Successful Workers' Rights Trial Law Firms In California

Hospital employee given chance to show disability bias at trial

California's 6th District Appellate Court recently remanded a case of disability discrimination back to the trial court level. The employee, who argues her firing was due to her struggles with PTSD and severe depression, now has a chance to have the motives of her firing examined by a trial court. 

This case presents several issues commonly encountered by wrongfully terminated employees, including mixed motives for firing and an employer's approach to mental health.

Background of Avery v. Community Hospital of the Monterey Peninsula

The plaintiff in this case worked as a systems analyst at the Community Hospital of the Monterey Peninsula for nearly twenty years prior to losing her job. About a year before she was fired, a supervisor spoke with her about some performance issues that were causing concern. At that time, it seems, the hospital was aware that the plaintiff was struggling with worry over her husband’s health issues. But, the employee insisted she would do better. Her supervisor supplied her with information about an assistance program for employees at the hospital and told her she should consider taking time off to “get her head together.”

When the plaintiff's job performance continued to suffer, the hospital placed her on a performance improvement plan. Eventually, the hospital placed her on a week-long suspension. Shortly after, a clinical psychologist notified the hospital that the plaintiff had a "serious health condition" and should take a medical leave of absence. She was fired just a few days later. 

California law protects employees suffering from mental health issues

Under the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), an employer cannot fire an employee because of a medical condition or physical/mental disability. However, determining an employer's motivations in terminating an employee is not always easy. As the court of appeals pointed out, a plaintiff in this kind of case has an opportunity to prove that their disability was a substantial factor in losing their job. 

In this case, the hospital doesn't dispute that the plaintiff was suffering from depression. The court found that performance reports by her supervisor indicate that the supervisor may have known that mental health issues were to blame for the plaintiff's dip in job performance. According to the court's opinion, an email between supervisors about the plaintiff even mentioned a "possible disability". Considering all this, the court found there was enough evidence to warrant allowing the plaintiff to take her disability bias claim to trial.

Source: Avery v. Community Hospital of the Monterey Peninsula, Calif. Ct. App., No. H042030 (Oct. 15, 2018), full opinion here

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  • Super lawyers
  • California Employment Lawyers Association
  • Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles

What Our Clients Say About Us

  1. I needed great attorneys in a short period of time, it was an emergency situation. Some research led me to the Hennig, Ruiz & Singh. We spoke on the phone and they had me come into the office and started on my case immediately. They got me exactly what I wanted and did it in the shortest amount of time possible. They were caring, fair and extremely good at what they do. I definitely would recommend them to anyone. -Scott Rooney

  2. If you are looking for legal representation I would suggest for you to consider Hennig, Ruiz & Singh. Put succinctly, their legal team was intelligent, hard working, responsive, and very knowledgeable throughout our time working together. While I of course cannot divulge details about the assistance that the firm provided for me, I can and will say that their representation was pivotal and changed my life for the better beyond words... -Shane Guglielmo

  3. I went to this firm to have a separation letter reviewed and met a young lawyer named Janet Hong. She was extremely friendly, professional, thorough and quick. She reviewed the documentation promptly and gave me actionable advice. I was able to resolve everything quickly. I would not hesitate to recommend Janet to anyone seeking legal services. -Brendan Hagerty

Schedule a Free Consultation

Ready To Start Protecting Your Rights? Call 213-985-1305

Not Sure Whether You Need Lawyer?

Answer a few questions to see whether you have a case.
Get Started Here

Office Location

Hennig Ruiz & Singh
3600 Wilshire Blvd.
Suite 1908
Los Angeles, CA 90010

Toll Free: 800-260-6542
Fax: (213) 310-8302
Map & Directions

Free Consultations

Contact Us