Los Angeles Office Location
Hennig Ruiz & Singh
Not sure if you have a legal case? Call us to talk to a lawyer:
Free Consultations
One Of The Most Successful Workers' Rights Trial Law Firms In California

Former Uc Berkeley Law School Dean Accused Of Sexual Harassment Sues School For Race Discrimination

uc-berkeley-law-school-dean-sues-race-discrimination-768x432.pngFormer UC Berkeley Law School Dean Sujit Choudhry, who resigned amidst allegations of sexual harassment and preferential treatment, claims that he is the victim of race discrimination.

In 2014 and 2015, Mr. Choudhry's former assistant, Tyann Sorrell, claims that he repeatedly harassed her through unsolicited touches that included hugs, kisses and arm rubs. At a University disciplinary hearing, Mr. Choudhry admitted to most of the allegations, but denied some of the specifics. The University ordered him to forfeit one-tenth of his $415,000 annual salary, apologize to Ms. Sorrell, and seek counseling. Ms. Sorrell subsequently filed a federal lawsuit, claiming that she had been sexually harassed and that UC Berkeley essentially gave Mr. Choudhry "a slap on the wrist" in response. In the wake of that action, Mr. Choudhry resigned as dean but remained a tenured professor of law.

After University President Janet Napolitano sought additional sanctions against Mr. Choudhry, including removing his tenure and not giving him any classes to teach, he filed his own lawsuit. He alleged that white tenured professors accused of sexual harassment faced lesser punishment and that the University could not discipline him again over the same matter.

Mr. Choudhry demands unspecified damages and an injunction against further University disciplinary proceedings.

Alleged Race Discrimination in Employment

Mr. Choudhry's discrimination lawsuit is a disparate treatment action, since he claims that the University treated him differently because of his race. In these cases, sometimes there is direct evidence of discrimination. For example, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) has ruled that the phrase "recent college graduate" in employment listings violates the Age Discrimination in Employment Act; the agency has not made a similar finding regarding the phrase "digital native," but that may be next.

However, most racial discrimination cases rely on circumstantial evidence. According to the Supreme Court of the United States, the requirements for a prima facie I circumstantial case are:

  • Membership in a Protected Class: The complainant must belong to a protected class enumerated in the Civil Rights Act or other legislation (e.g. non-white, female, over 40, or disabled)
  • Otherwise Qualified: A paralegal cannot apply for a job as an auto mechanic and claim discrimination when the employer selects another candidate. Likewise, if the adverse decision is a demotion or termination, the complainant must have been performing the job adequately.
  • Damages: The complainant must have been fired, demoted, passed over for promotion, or otherwise have suffered some tangible harm.
  • Outcome: To make a prima facie case, the benefit (job or promotion) must either still be available, or it must have gone to a person who is outside the complainant's protected class (this means that if a disabled person complains, another disabled person cannot get the promotion).

To rebut a claim, the employer can produce a nondiscriminatory reason for the adverse action. For example, ABC company can claim that it fired a worker because of poor performance reviews and not because the worker was black. The claimant can then counter that this justification was simply a pretext for discrimination.

In the above case, Mr. Choudhry, who is of Indian descent, claims that he was treated differently than two other non-Indian employees in similar situations, and that he is ineligible for pay increases because he is not teaching classes. In response, UC Berkeley has two basic arguments. First, Mr. Choudhry is still a tenured professor and has therefore hast not sustained damages.

Secondly, although the other two professors may have been in similar situations, neither one of them had been the dean of the law school.

If you feel you are a victim of race discrimination at work, our California employment attorneys are here to fight for your employee rights. Contact our passionate legal team at Hennig Ruiz for a free consultation today.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  • Super lawyers
  • California Employment Lawyers Association
  • Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles

What Our Clients Say About Us

  1. I needed great attorneys in a short period of time, it was an emergency situation. Some research led me to the Hennig, Ruiz & Singh. We spoke on the phone and they had me come into the office and started on my case immediately. They got me exactly what I wanted and did it in the shortest amount of time possible. They were caring, fair and extremely good at what they do. I definitely would recommend them to anyone. -Scott Rooney

  2. If you are looking for legal representation I would suggest for you to consider Hennig, Ruiz & Singh. Put succinctly, their legal team was intelligent, hard working, responsive, and very knowledgeable throughout our time working together. While I of course cannot divulge details about the assistance that the firm provided for me, I can and will say that their representation was pivotal and changed my life for the better beyond words... -Shane Guglielmo

  3. I went to this firm to have a separation letter reviewed and met a young lawyer named Janet Hong. She was extremely friendly, professional, thorough and quick. She reviewed the documentation promptly and gave me actionable advice. I was able to resolve everything quickly. I would not hesitate to recommend Janet to anyone seeking legal services. -Brendan Hagerty

Schedule a Free Consultation

Ready To Start Protecting Your Rights? Call 213-985-1305

Not Sure Whether You Need Lawyer?

Answer a few questions to see whether you have a case.
Get Started Here

Office Location

Hennig Ruiz & Singh
3600 Wilshire Blvd.
Suite 1908
Los Angeles, CA 90010

Toll Free: 800-260-6542
Fax: (213) 310-8302
Map & Directions

Free Consultations

Contact Us